Without question, A+ on quality for both coats! I tried the Jane B-3 bomber at first. It was just too much coat... heavy, with tiny pockets, and just made me look "thick". Though I loved it on the hanger, I didn't love it on, so it had to go back. (A+ on return process and policy, too!) So I got the Lacey instead, and it was the right choice for me. I loved it at first sight, but was concerned about the shorter length. Turns out the coverage is just right. I do have a shorter torso, so might be too short on some. The interior is silky soft (Jane was coarse). The pockets are bigger than Jane, and have zippers so that phone won't slip out. Looks great zipped or open. Luxurious warmth, but still wearable on 40ish-degree days, whereas you would melt in the Jane in slightly warmer temps. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is the sleeves could be a tad longer for me. I do have long arms, though. The Lacey does cover my arms but just an inch more would have been perfect.