I was looking for a Spanish Merino sheepskin coat that is made in the USA. I did a lot of research and chose Overland for a lot of reasons. I bought it from their website, so I don't have a hands-on comparison to the other Overland coats, but this one checked all the boxes at a surprisingly lower price point. I strongly considered the McKinley and was willing to pay the premium but at 38" it's just too long for me. When I received the Anderson, I was blown away by the overall craftsmanship and impressed by the little details, e.g. the stitching around the collar. It's an investment worth every penny.