Perfect in NYC
When I first ordered this coat, I followed what most others wrote about sizing up due to tight arms. Size M was way too large in the arms and shoulders. I returned for a size S (very easy returns btw), and it fit perfectly. For reference my measurements are 36, 28, 38 (small bone frame). It is more fitted on the arms but nothing too tight or uncomfortable. Everyone's weight is distributed differently on their bodies. Maybe take that into account when trying this coat. I also don't wear my extra thick winter sweaters when wearing this coat, as I find it keeps me incredibly warm. The brown color (antique frost) is beautiful, and great quality. I see myself keeping this coat for years to come, and see my daughter want to wear it when she's old enough.