Nice glove, but not really warm
I found this glove to fit well, the liner feels nice and it's not too bulky. The outside leather is soft and supple. They don't, however, make my hands feel warm.
If you put them on cold, they will take a while to warm up. It may be the effect of the liner because I tried on the shearling lined Hayes jacket and felt the same, the liner has a cooling effect that takes a while to warm up.
At times, my pinky and ring fingers felt cold after having been worn and "warmed up". This was in weather in the 20s-30s F.
That being said, I do like them and would purchase them again.